She Chose My Stepsister. I Chose the Head Cheerleader
Riley secretly dates Claire as a way to get closer to Madison, the girl she truly wants. But when a photo of them together goes public, Claire discovers Riley’s deception, ends the relationship, and is left heartbroken and abandoned. Just when Claire hits rock bottom, Avery, a popular cheerleader, enters her life and offers unexpected comfort. As they grow closer, Claire begins to uncover a truth she never saw coming: Avery was never really a stranger, but someone who has quietly loved her for years.